The Coast Guard hate symbols policy became a major subject of public debate in November 2025 after changes to a workplace harassment manual raised concerns about how the service classified swastikas, nooses, and other extremist imagery. Critics questioned why symbols associated with Nazi persecution and racial terror appeared under the description “potentially divisive” rather than the earlier hate-incident terminology.
The controversy prompted congressional questions and a response from Admiral Kevin Lunday, the Acting Commandant of the United States Coast Guard. On November 20, 2025, Lunday issued a separate lawful order explicitly prohibiting divisive and hate symbols. The Coast Guard later issued another policy statement and lawful order on December 12, 2025.
These developments created an important distinction between the disputed wording in the harassment manual and the service’s actual prohibition on hate symbols. Understanding that difference helps explain what happened, why people objected, and what Coast Guard personnel must follow.
What Is the Coast Guard Hate Symbols Policy?
The Coast Guard hate symbols policy prohibits personnel from displaying, distributing, or using symbols and flags associated with hatred, oppression, racial supremacy, religious intolerance, antisemitism, and other forms of improper bias.
The policy protects the professional environment across Coast Guard workplaces, facilities, and assets. It also supports good order and discipline, unit cohesion, employee morale, and mission effectiveness.
The Coast Guard operates under the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) rather than the Department of Defense. However, its military members remain subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ).
The December 12, 2025 policy statement specifically identifies several prohibited categories:
- Swastikas associated with Nazi ideology and antisemitism.
- Nooses associated with racial hatred and intimidation.
- Symbols and flags adopted by hate-based groups.
- Imagery representing white supremacy or racial intolerance.
- Symbols promoting religious intolerance or antisemitism.
- Other displays that undermine military discipline or workplace safety.
The order applies to all Coast Guard personnel. Military members subject to the UCMJ can also face punishment under Article 92(1) for violating a lawful general order.
Importantly, the Coast Guard does not rely on a fixed list of every prohibited image. Extremist organizations can adopt new symbols or give existing imagery different meanings. Therefore, the policy also considers the circumstances surrounding unfamiliar displays.
What Happened in the 2025 Coast Guard Hate Symbols Controversy?
The controversy began when the Coast Guard revised its workplace harassment instruction in November 2025. The revised wording described swastikas, nooses, and certain other imagery as potentially divisive symbols and flags.
Previously, the Coast Guard’s 2023 harassment instruction identified these displays as potential hate incidents. The change attracted criticism because it appeared to soften the classification of symbols with well-documented histories of racial and religious hatred.
The difference mattered. A hate-incident classification communicates that a display may involve conduct motivated by prejudice and intimidation. The phrase potentially divisive can sound broader and less direct.
Critics questioned whether the revised terminology would weaken investigations or reduce accountability. They also raised concerns about how supervisors would interpret the new language.
The Coast Guard defended its position. Admiral Kevin Lunday maintained that the service never intended to permit swastikas, nooses, or other recognized hate symbols.
On November 20, he issued a separate policy and lawful order that explicitly prohibited these displays. The order stated that prohibited symbols must be removed from Coast Guard workplaces, facilities, and assets.
The service later clarified its position through a December policy statement. It also removed the disputed language from the relevant harassment policy manual.
Coast Guard Hate Symbols Policy Timeline: 2023–2025
The following timeline explains the major developments behind the controversy.
| Date | Important development |
| February 2023 | Earlier harassment guidance identified swastikas, nooses, and other extremist imagery as potential hate incidents. |
| March 2025 | The Coast Guard updated its Civil Rights Manual. |
| November 2025 | Revised harassment guidance introduced the controversial potentially divisive terminology. |
| November 20, 2025 | Admiral Kevin Lunday issued a separate lawful order explicitly prohibiting hate symbols and flags. |
| December 12, 2025 | The Commandant issued another policy statement and lawful order. |
| December 18, 2025 | The Coast Guard announced the removal of the disputed language from its harassment policy manual. |
The timeline shows why describing the controversy as a simple cancellation of the hate-symbol ban would be misleading. The wording changed, public criticism followed, and leadership issued additional instructions to clarify the prohibition.
Why Did the Coast Guard’s Hate Symbol Reclassification Trigger Backlash?
The backlash centered on the difference between identifying an image as a potential hate incident and describing it as potentially divisive.
Although these phrases may seem similar at first, they communicate different things. A hate incident specifically involves conduct or expression connected to bias and intimidation. A divisive symbol can describe a wider category of imagery that creates conflict or damages workplace cohesion.
Critics argued that the revised terminology failed to reflect the historical seriousness of swastikas and nooses.
Concerns About Swastikas and Nazi Symbolism
The Nazi swastika represents one of history’s most recognizable symbols of antisemitism, racial supremacy, and genocide.
Under Adolf Hitler, the Nazi Party adopted the symbol as an emblem of its political movement. Nazi propaganda used it throughout Germany and occupied territories during World War II.
The regime also used racial ideology to justify persecution, forced displacement, and mass murder. The Holocaust resulted in the murder of approximately six million European Jews.
Consequently, the Nazi swastika carries a meaning strongly connected with persecution and organized hatred.
Critics argued that describing this imagery as merely potentially divisive understated its historical significance. They wanted the Coast Guard to maintain clear language identifying it as prohibited hate imagery.
However, historical accuracy requires an important distinction. The swastika existed for centuries before Nazi Germany adopted it. Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism use traditional versions in religious and cultural settings. Their meanings differ significantly from Nazi symbolism.
Concerns About Nooses and Racial Terror
A noose is a loop of rope historically associated with hanging. In the United States, it also became a powerful symbol of racial intimidation and white supremacist violence.
During the era of racial lynching, mobs used hanging as a method of terror against Black Americans. These killings frequently occurred outside lawful judicial processes and served to maintain racial oppression.
Nooses continued to appear as threats and intimidation during the Civil Rights Movement. Their presence could communicate a warning of racial violence even without an accompanying verbal threat.
Today, displaying a noose in a workplace can create fear and hostility among employees. Its historical association with lynching makes it especially significant in discussions of racial discrimination.
For this reason, the Coast Guard specifically identifies nooses as prohibited symbols.
Questions About Military Discipline and Enforcement
The controversy also raised questions about military accountability.
Personnel need clear instructions about which displays violate regulations and how supervisors should respond. Ambiguous wording can create inconsistent decisions across different units.
Critics worried that weaker terminology could affect reporting and investigations. They also questioned whether commanding officers would have enough guidance to address incidents consistently.
These concerns extended beyond symbolism. They involved workplace protections, military leadership, and confidence in the Coast Guard’s commitment to opposing discrimination.
What Does the Current Coast Guard Hate Symbols Policy Prohibit?
The December 12, 2025 Divisive or Hate Symbols and Flags Policy Statement and Lawful Order provides direct guidance.
It prohibits divisive or hate symbols and flags that adversely affect good order and discipline, unit cohesion, command climate, morale, or mission effectiveness.
The order identifies specific examples while allowing commanders to assess other extremist imagery.
Swastikas and Nazi Symbols
The Coast Guard expressly prohibits swastikas associated with Nazi ideology and hatred.
This includes displays that promote racial supremacy, antisemitism, or extremist beliefs. Personnel cannot use workplace displays to promote Nazi imagery or related hate-based messages.
The prohibition reflects the symbol’s connection with oppression and hatred in its Nazi context.
Nooses and Symbols of Racial Terror
Nooses also appear explicitly in the policy.
The Coast Guard prohibits their display as symbols of hatred or intimidation. Their historical connection with lynching and racial terror explains why the order identifies them directly.
A noose displayed as a threat or expression of racial hostility has no place in a professional military environment.
Confederate Battle Flags
The policy also maintains restrictions on displaying or depicting the Confederate battle flag.
These restrictions cover:
- Coast Guard workplaces and facilities.
- Barracks and other quarters where the flag remains readily visible.
- Exterior displays on Coast Guard housing.
- Clothing and other apparel.
- Vehicle decorations and bumper stickers.
- Flags displayed inside vehicles when readily visible to the public.
The order includes limited exceptions. State flags and state-issued license plates do not fall under this prohibition. Historical, educational, or artistic displays can also qualify when the Confederate battle flag appears only as an incidental or minor component.
Other Extremist Symbols and Flags
The policy does not stop with three examples.
It also covers symbols or flags adopted by hate-based groups to represent:
- White supremacy and racial superiority.
- Racial intolerance and discrimination.
- Religious intolerance.
- Antisemitism and Nazi ideology.
- Other forms of improper bias.
This broader approach matters because extremist groups frequently change their names, visual identities, and symbols.
A symbol’s meaning may also depend on how someone uses it. Therefore, the Coast Guard evaluates unfamiliar imagery using the policy’s standards rather than relying exclusively on a permanent symbol list.
Clothing, Vehicles, Facilities, and Other Displays
The prohibition reaches beyond posters or flags hanging inside offices.
It includes clothing, apparel, vehicle decorations, and displays across Coast Guard facilities and assets.
The purpose is to prevent prohibited imagery from appearing in professional settings where personnel must work together.
How Does the Coast Guard Determine Whether a Symbol Is Prohibited?
The policy establishes different considerations for widely recognized hate symbols and less familiar imagery.
For example, the December order explicitly identifies swastikas and nooses. These recognized symbols do not require commanders to decide whether they are prohibited.
Other symbols may need closer examination.
Widely Recognized Hate Symbols
The policy identifies swastikas and nooses as prohibited. It also covers symbols associated with recognized hate-based movements.
Their established historical meaning provides a clear basis for enforcement.
Symbols Adopted or Co-opted by Hate Groups
Some extremist organizations use symbols that originally had different meanings.
A group may adopt an ordinary image, number, flag, or phrase and turn it into a representation of supremacy or intolerance.
The Coast Guard therefore avoids relying on an exhaustive list. Instead, it considers whether a symbol has been adopted by a hate-based group and whether its display harms the workplace environment.
Role of Commanders and Supervisors

Commanders, commanding officers, officers-in-charge, and supervisors have specific responsibilities.
They must:
- Direct the removal of prohibited symbols and flags.
- Examine other potentially divisive displays.
- Consult their servicing legal office when necessary.
- Notify the appropriate chain of command.
- Take suitable disciplinary or administrative action when extremist activity appears involved.
This process helps balance clear restrictions with fair treatment when an unfamiliar symbol requires further investigation.
What Happens If Coast Guard Personnel Display Hate Symbols?
Displaying prohibited imagery can trigger removal orders, investigations, and disciplinary proceedings.
The exact response depends on the person’s status, the applicable policy, and the circumstances surrounding the incident.
Reporting a Potential Hate Incident
Personnel can report suspected hate incidents through the Coast Guard’s established civil rights and harassment procedures.
The Coast Guard Civil Rights Manual includes specific provisions for:
- Chapter 3F: Hate Incidents and CO/OIC Responsibilities.
- Chapter 3G: Notification and Processing for Potential and Actual Hate Incidents.
These chapters address command responsibilities and the handling of reported incidents.
A person reporting an incident should provide relevant details, such as the location, date, nature of the display, and available evidence.
Investigation and Evidence Collection
Commanders and supervisors must respond to reports appropriately.
Depending on the circumstances, they may need to gather evidence, interview witnesses, document the incident, and consult legal authorities.
The Coast Guard Investigative Service (CGIS) may become involved when an incident requires a criminal or specialized investigation.
The purpose is to establish what happened and determine whether someone violated applicable rules.
Disciplinary and Administrative Consequences
The December 2025 order also establishes a punitive general order for personnel subject to the UCMJ.
Under Article 92(1), service members can face punishment for violating or failing to obey a lawful general order or regulation.
Possible consequences depend on the evidence and applicable military law. Civilian Coast Guard employees follow separate disciplinary and administrative procedures.
Therefore, it would be inaccurate to suggest that every incident automatically results in the same punishment.
November vs. December 2025 Coast Guard Hate Symbols Orders
Both orders reinforced the prohibition. However, the December statement provided a later formal clarification.
| Policy element | November 20 order | December 12 order |
| Issuing authority | Admiral Kevin Lunday | Admiral Kevin Lunday |
| Main purpose | Explicitly prohibit divisive and hate symbols | Restate and clarify the prohibition |
| Swastikas | Prohibited | Prohibited |
| Nooses | Prohibited | Prohibited |
| Confederate battle flag | Prohibited with specified exceptions | Prohibited with specified exceptions |
| Other extremist imagery | Covered | Covered |
| Personnel coverage | All Coast Guard personnel | All Coast Guard personnel |
| UCMJ enforcement | Lawful general order | Punitive general order under Article 92(1) |
| Hate incident procedures | Existing civil rights procedures remain relevant | Chapters 3F and 3G remain controlling |
Did the Coast Guard Actually Reverse Its Hate Symbol Ban?
The controversy involved a genuine change in the wording of the harassment instruction. However, the Coast Guard maintained that it never intended to remove the prohibition against recognized hate symbols.
The November 20 order expressly prohibited swastikas and nooses. The December 12 statement reinforced those restrictions.
The service also removed the disputed terminology from its harassment manual in December.
Therefore, the most accurate description is that the Coast Guard faced criticism over a controversial reclassification in its workplace harassment guidance and subsequently clarified and reinforced its prohibition through separate lawful orders.
Who Was Involved in the Coast Guard Hate Symbols Controversy?
Several military leaders, government officials, and lawmakers became involved in the debate.
Admiral Kevin Lunday
Admiral Kevin E. Lunday served as Acting Commandant during the controversy.
He issued the November 20, 2025 lawful order and later signed the December policy statement.
During his Senate confirmation proceedings, Lunday defended the Coast Guard’s position. He stated that claims suggesting the service had declassified swastikas and nooses were categorically false.
His response emphasized that recognized hate symbols remained prohibited.
Lauren Underwood
Representative Lauren Underwood of Illinois raised concerns about the revised policy language.
Her involvement reflected congressional interest in how the Coast Guard classified and handled hate symbols.
She sought clarification from Lunday about the prohibition and the service’s commitment to preventing racial and religious discrimination.
Department of Homeland Security
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) oversees the Coast Guard.
However, Lunday stated in his Senate responses that DHS did not direct him or Coast Guard leadership to classify swastikas and nooses as potentially divisive.
The distinction matters because responsibility for issuing the November lawful order rested with Coast Guard leadership.
Congressional Oversight
Lawmakers questioned the policy’s wording, reporting requirements, and enforcement procedures.
Their concerns focused on whether the revised guidance could weaken accountability or create confusion among commanding officers.
The Senate confirmation process provided an opportunity to examine these issues publicly.
How Does the Coast Guard Address Extremism Within Its Ranks?
The controversy also connects with broader concerns about military extremism, white supremacy, and discriminatory behavior.
Military organizations depend on discipline, trust, and teamwork. Extremist activity can damage all three.
White Supremacy and Extremist Affiliations
White supremacy promotes the belief that white people possess inherent superiority over other racial groups.
Extremist organizations may use racist symbols, propaganda, recruitment material, and intimidation to spread these beliefs.
The Coast Guard’s policy addresses symbols adopted by hate-based groups when they represent supremacy or intolerance.
However, the policy does not mean that every controversial political opinion automatically constitutes prohibited extremist activity. Conduct, context, and applicable regulations matter.
Military Readiness and Unit Cohesion
A hostile workplace can weaken trust between service members.
Personnel need confidence that their colleagues and supervisors will treat them fairly. Racial intimidation and religious hostility can undermine that confidence.
A strong anti-hate policy helps protect:
- Workplace morale.
- Professional relationships.
- Unit cohesion.
- Military discipline.
- Operational effectiveness.
- Confidence in leadership.
These factors directly support the Coast Guard’s ability to carry out its missions.
Pentagon Efforts to Counter Military Extremism
The Department of Defense has also addressed extremism within the armed forces.
In 2021, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin directed military-wide discussions about extremism following concerns about extremist activity among service members.
The Department of Defense and Coast Guard operate under different departmental structures. Nevertheless, both recognize that extremist conduct can threaten military professionalism and institutional trust.
The Coast Guard’s specific orders and civil rights procedures govern its personnel.
Why Clear Hate Symbol Policies Matter in the US Military
Clear policies help personnel understand what conduct crosses the line and how leadership must respond.
Without consistent rules, similar incidents may receive different treatment across units. That inconsistency can damage confidence in military leadership.
The Coast Guard controversy demonstrated why policy wording matters as much as enforcement. Even when leadership maintains that a prohibition remains unchanged, unclear terminology can create public confusion.
A well-defined policy should provide:
- Clear examples of prohibited symbols.
- Consistent reporting and investigation procedures.
- Defined responsibilities for supervisors.
- Fair and lawful disciplinary processes.
- Protection against racial and religious intimidation.
- Guidance for historical and educational displays.
The Coast Guard’s December 2025 order addresses several of these concerns by identifying prohibited imagery and outlining command responsibilities.
Ultimately, the objective extends beyond removing offensive pictures or flags. It involves maintaining a workplace where personnel can serve without facing intimidation based on race, religion, or other protected characteristics.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Coast Guard Hate Symbols Policy
Does the US Coast Guard prohibit swastikas and nooses?
Yes. The Coast Guard’s December 12, 2025 policy explicitly prohibits displaying swastikas and nooses as divisive or hate symbols. The prohibition applies across Coast Guard workplaces, facilities, and assets.
Why did the Coast Guard change its hate symbol policy in 2025?
A revised harassment instruction used the phrase potentially divisive symbols and flags when describing swastikas, nooses, and other imagery. The wording triggered criticism because it appeared to soften their earlier classification as potential hate incidents.
Did the Coast Guard reclassify swastikas and nooses?
The November 2025 harassment instruction introduced different terminology. However, Admiral Kevin Lunday maintained that the Coast Guard never intended to remove the prohibition against these recognized hate symbols.
What did Admiral Kevin Lunday say about the controversy?
Lunday said the Coast Guard continued to prohibit hate symbols. He issued a November 20, 2025 lawful order to clarify the prohibition and followed it with a December policy statement.
What is the December 2025 Coast Guard hate symbols order?
It is a policy statement and lawful order signed on December 12, 2025. It prohibits divisive or hate symbols and flags, including swastikas, nooses, and imagery adopted by hate-based groups.
Are Confederate flags prohibited in Coast Guard workplaces?
Yes. The policy prohibits Confederate battle flag displays in Coast Guard workplaces, facilities, and assets. It includes specified exceptions for state-issued items and incidental historical or educational depictions.
Can Coast Guard personnel display extremist symbols on clothing or vehicles?
No, when those displays fall under the prohibition. The policy specifically covers clothing, apparel, vehicle decorations, and visible Confederate battle flag displays.
What happens when a Coast Guard member displays a hate symbol?
Commanders can order its removal and initiate appropriate inquiries or investigations. Military members may face UCMJ action, including proceedings under Article 92(1).
Does the hate symbols policy apply to civilian Coast Guard employees?
Yes. The December policy applies to all Coast Guard personnel. However, civilian employees follow applicable civilian disciplinary procedures rather than military punishment under the UCMJ.
How does the Coast Guard investigate hate incidents?
The Coast Guard uses its Civil Rights Manual, including Chapters 3F and 3G, to guide reporting, command responsibilities, and incident processing. Investigative authorities may become involved when circumstances require them.
Can historical or educational displays include controversial symbols?
Some displays may qualify for specific exceptions. For example, the policy permits certain incidental or minor depictions of the Confederate battle flag in historical, educational, or artistic contexts. The circumstances and applicable rules determine whether a display qualifies.
Conclusion: Understanding the Coast Guard Hate Symbols Policy
The Coast Guard hate symbols policy controversy highlighted the importance of clear language, consistent enforcement, and military accountability.The November 2025 revisions raised concerns because they described swastikas and nooses using potentially divisive terminology. Admiral Kevin Lunday responded with a separate lawful order explicitly prohibiting these symbols. The December 12 policy statement reinforced the restrictions and established a punitive general order for personnel subject to the UCMJ.The key distinction is that the Coast Guard defended the continuing prohibition while facing criticism over how its harassment guidance described hate symbols.Ultimately, military personnel must follow the applicable restrictions and reporting procedures. Clear policies help protect service members, strengthen unit cohesion, and prevent racial and religious intimidation from undermining the Coast Guard’s mission.

I am Lisa Reynolds, a linguist fascinated by the ever-changing world of slang. I enjoy researching how slang reflects trends, technology, and social connections. I wrote “Text Talk: Understanding Digital Slang” and “From Street to Screen: Slang in Media”, exploring the influence of digital communication on language. I love sharing my discoveries in a way that feels like a conversation with friends, so you feel the culture and humor behind every phrase.
